Hire the person who asks you the most questions. The best DJs in New England interview you harder than you interview them.
The night rises or falls on one person
I have stood at the back of a lot of receptions in Vermont, New Hampshire, Maine and Massachusetts, and I can tell you the moment a wedding turns. It is not the ceremony, and it is not dinner. It is the first twenty minutes after the plates are cleared, when the room either gets up or settles into its chairs for the night. The person holding that moment is your DJ.
So when couples ask me what to look for, I do not start with gear lists or music libraries. I start with temperament. Your DJ is the only vendor who will speak to every one of your guests, out loud, all night. They set the volume of the room in every sense of that word.
Everything below is what I tell my own clients when they sit down with me to build a shortlist on the 802 Events planner. It is the same list I use when I decide which entertainers earn a place in our New England vendor stories.
One: a voice you would happily listen to for five hours
Ask for a recording of them on a microphone. Not a mixed song, not a highlight reel with music under it. A raw clip of them introducing a wedding party or reading a name. You are going to hear that voice for five hours, and so is your grandmother.
What you want is warm and unhurried. What you do not want is radio-announcer theater, the big booming voice that turns your reception into a car dealership commercial. There is a reason the highest-reviewed entertainers on this site, people like Supersounds Entertainment in Underhill, Vermont, get described in their reviews as calm rather than loud. Calm reads as confident.
Two: real reading of a real room
Reading a room is the whole craft, and it is almost impossible to fake. A DJ who reads well is watching the bar, the hallway, the tables of teenagers and the tables of great-aunts, and adjusting in three-song increments. A DJ who does not read well is playing a set list they printed on Tuesday.
Ask a simple question: tell me about a night where your plan stopped working, and what you did. If they cannot name one, they have either not worked enough weddings or they are not paying attention during them. Every honest entertainer I know has three of those stories ready.
I have watched Main Event Entertainment out of Londonderry, New Hampshire pivot an entire evening after a late ceremony ate forty minutes, and the guests never knew anything had gone sideways. That is what you are buying.
Three: their own equipment, and a backup for it
You want a DJ who owns their gear rather than renting it the morning of, and you want to hear the word redundancy come out of their mouth without prompting. Two laptops. A backup controller. A spare wireless microphone that lives in the case and never gets used except for the one night it saves the toasts.
Ask what happens if the power flickers, which in a Vermont barn in September is not a hypothetical. The good answer is specific and slightly boring. The bad answer is a shrug and a promise that it has never happened.
Four: a planning process you can see
Before you book, ask to see their planning paperwork. A professional will have a timeline document, a music preferences form, a do-not-play list and a pronunciation sheet for names. If all they have is a contract and a friendly attitude, you will be doing the organizing yourself at eleven at night three weeks before the wedding.
This matters more than people expect, because your DJ usually ends up running the room. They cue the caterer, they find the photographer before the first dance, they know when the sun sets and the toasts need to move. Ask your venue who they trust with that job. Many of the barns and inns in our Vermont wedding venues guide keep an informal list, and it is usually a very accurate one.
Five: reviews that mention the guests, not the DJ
Read past the five stars and look at the nouns. Reviews that say the dance floor was full all night, that nobody sat down, that the parents were still out there at the end, tell you far more than reviews praising the DJ's personality. You are not hiring a performer. You are hiring the result.
When you scan our entertainment listings, you will see review counts alongside every rating, because a perfect score across eight reviews is a different animal from a near-perfect score across six hundred. Both can be excellent. Only one has been tested.
What does not matter as much as you think
The size of their music library is irrelevant. Everyone has everything now. Lighting packages are nice, and uplighting genuinely warms a plain room, but no amount of lighting rescues a DJ who cannot sequence a dance set. And the fanciest booth facade in New England has never made a single guest get up.
Price sits somewhere in the middle. It matters, but not the way couples treat it. Spending more does not guarantee a better night; spending far too little almost guarantees a worse one, because the people who work for very little are usually the people still learning.
How I would actually do it
Shortlist three entertainers who work regularly near your venue. Get all three on a video call for twenty minutes each. Ask about a night that went wrong, ask to hear their microphone voice, and ask who they last worked with at your venue. Then pick the one you felt easiest talking to, because that feeling is the same one your guests will have.
When you are ready, put your night together on the 802 Events checklist, pick your people, and send the whole list out at once. It is free, and the DJs who are open on your date will come back to you rather than the other way around. If you want to browse first, every entertainer we have researched is in the full vendor directory with their town, rating and real Google reviews.
Ready when you are
Put your night together and send it to everyone at once.
It is free, it takes a few minutes, and only the people you choose hear from you. Start on the 802 Events planner or browse the New England vendor directory first.
Keep reading
10 suggestions in this collection.
